Blogs

Pastor Andrew Ray is a pastor I had learned to trust and respect after several years in spiritually abusive situations. He had proved himself to be fair and honest, though with his own unique flaws, and his manner, unlike Douglas Stauffer’s, lent itself to an atmosphere of resolving issues with mutual respect and understanding. Just one week after Douglas Stauffer’s carnal message and my public Facebook post to call out the atrocities of that message and two others from Stauffer in recent months about the same topic, Matthew Olds and I walked hesitantly into the room to work through any miscommunications from Matt’s midweek meeting with Pastor Ray, when Pastor removed me and my husband from all ministries.

The toddler’s Sunday school classroom was the only other closed-off room besides Pastor’s office. Stauffer had already overtaken Pastor’s office with studio equipment and his own personal books to sell, and not only was one specific piece of equipment triggering from my past, but I did not trust Stauffer not to use any one of his plethora of devices to record the meeting without our knowledge. As we took our seats in the black folding chairs left from the Bible Conference, my mind raced through the difficulties of the previous week, made even more complicated by our pastor’s family informing us the night before that they were still expecting graciously allowing us to serve in the nursery and lead in the greeter ministry, both ministries that were incessantly short-handed since we lost about one-third of the church members last fall.

Internal Struggles

For the first time since Sunday, I was going to face my pastor and hopefully without the uncontrollable waterworks that prevented me from meeting with him Tuesday night. I felt immensely guilty and burdened by the idea that I had hurt my pastor’s family so deeply, and the wounds still burned from Pastor’s private messages to my husband about the writing being on the wall. On the other hand, I felt the resolve to stand my ground about being used for nursery when I had been forced repeatedly to concede throughout the week. Still yet, my husband pleaded with me to purposefully work towards a calm and peaceful resolution as to not harm his ability to serve any further. I needed to balance keeping my own boundaries while submitting to my husband and preferring others above myself.

I trusted Pastor Andrew Ray. He and I did not agree on everything, but I wanted to continue to trust my pastor despite the influence I believed Stauffer had over him, slowly shaping his mentality towards being overly critical, filled with paranoia, and needing a following to be established as an authority in the eyes of men. Unfortunately, I did not fully anticipate the strength of Pastor Ray and Doug Stauffer’s bond, nor did I realize how much the inner circle’s gossip would play a role in the meeting to come. My own pastor successfully manipulated us into a corner to get information, defended Stauffer and expressed his opinion that we should share more personal information with Stauffer, and justified his own actions from the fall while deceitfully implicating those who left.  And yet, because of what we feel was love-bombing and gaslighting, we initially left believing the meeting with Pastor Ray to have been reassuring, successful, and steered in the right direction towards reconciliation. If only we had an idea of whom our Pastor had become prior to the meeting, rather than being completely blindsided again by his behavior.

In this series I share my thoughts and opinions concerning these ministers and the events which led to my departure. Click here to continue reading: “Blindsided: Our Pastor’s True Colors Begin to Show (Part One)” or click on the link below.

For a list of the complete series, click here.

********
Shop at our Amazon store! As an Amazon Influencer, this website earns from qualifying purchases.

In addition to the stress within our own household the week of Bible Conference, I remembered that I was previously scheduled for Sunday School nursery. Surely, the gossip chain had carried far and fast enough for even the results of a private meeting to be shared amongst the inner circle, right? In our second meeting Tuesday evening, Pastor Andrew Ray removed Matthew Olds and I from all ministries for the unforeseeable future because “the men of the church [had] lost faith in [Matt].”

Would this hold true for serving in nursery as well, once the pastor realized that he shot himself in the foot?  Of course not, but it would be unsubmissive of me to refuse when working nursery was to their benefit, a last-minute exception to the shameful and one-sided punishment! I stood my ground, resulting in not only a greater strain in our marriage, but in giving the inner circle more ground to view my husband as less of a man and even less of a leader in our home.

**Names marked with an asterisk (*) have been changed for the privacy of individuals and their families**

Treading Thin Ice

Prior to meeting with Douglas Stauffer and Pastor Ray on Tuesday evening, I messaged my pastor’s wife, Lula Ray, about working in nursery the week of conference:

“Crystal Olds (June 9 at 12:27pm):  I am not discussing the situation, but since I am not in nursery tonight supposedly, am I taking someone’s place another night? We won’t be there for the second preacher any night because of Matt’s work.”

As of that point in the timeline of events, I was only aware of Douglas Stauffer asserting that I would not work in the nursery, not our actual pastor. Lula’s response was, “I am not involved in any of this.” Combine that with Pastor Andrew Ray cutting off certain communication between our families, there was no one else to bring the issue to besides Emily Jenkins* the one who organized the nursery schedule.

Even though Emily* and I have had past conflicts about breastfeeding in the church service and despite that our opinions still differed significantly, we had finally come to a form of respect and understanding about the other person’s position because of the effects of postpartum mood disorders. The last thing I wanted to do was strain that relationship more by potentially leaving her without a nursery worker on Sunday morning, especially during a time when her family was preparing for the arrival of their third child. I politely sent her this carefully-worded text message to make sure that she was aware:

Crystal Olds (June 9 at 5:47pm): Hey Emily*, I’ve been assuming that you already know that I won’t be working nursery for the foreseeable future, but I didn’t want you to be caught off guard just in case. If you’d prefer, I can just keep Joshua* upstairs for Sunday school for the month of June and just go down with him myself as necessary since he is the only one. Praying for you and Baby Eliana*. We can’t wait to meet her!

 

 

 

 

 

Response from Pastor’s Family

After messaging Emily*, I received a response back from Lula Ray, my pastor’s wife:

Lula Ray (June 9 at 5:55pm): Crystal, Emily* forwarded me your text about nursery. I had asked my husband earlier today about it, and he said it was fine to keep you on the schedule.

Is this ok with you?

Though the message was likely specifically filtered through her husband to remove the flair of southern charm, the response was still what we expected. Despite Pastor removing Matt and I from all ministries, greeting included, serving in nursery would be the exception to the rule. Was it because of a lack of workers or to keep my nursling out of the service as much as possible? We will never know, but I refused to be used by allowing them to take advantage of my desire to serve the Lord. My husband and I, both initially enraged by the expectation to continue in nursery, discussed how to handle the situation and decided that I would not be working in the nursery until we were clear to serve in ministries again.

Phone Call with Pastor Andrew Ray

According to a phone conversation between Matthew Olds and Pastor Andrew Ray that evening, when Pastor Ray had said on Tuesday night that all Matt could do was be faithful to church, sing the hymns, and say “Amen,” he also meant that he could still do the greeter ministry and I could serve in nursery. Both of these ministries were extremely short-handed as a result of the mass exodus last fall. My husband, blinded by the relief and excitement of being able to serve the Lord again even in the smallest capacity, could not see the psychological abuse of having everything taken away, followed by getting back a minuscule and insignificant portion, wrapped up in the disguise of expressing that they loved our family and wanted to see us restored. Matt and Pastor Ray set up a meeting for the following day to clarify any other confusion in this situation. Matt said he would allow me to decide about nursery, but he told Pastor Ray that he was thankful and ready to serve in the greeter ministry the next day.

Our House Divided Yet More

Because of my experience in a spiritually abusive environment in high school and college, and after seeing how Douglas Stauffer, the pastor’s ascending right-hand man, attempted to control our every move for the past week, I refused. Matt was infuriated because Pastor was gracious enough to allow us to continue to serve and I was potentially going to make the situation worse by standing my ground. For my husband’s sake, I resolved to look at the decision again after the meeting with Pastor on Sunday. Filtered through my husband, I sent the following message back to Lula Ray:

Crystal Olds (June 9 at 7:06pm): Matt and I talked right after getting off of the phone with Pastor a few minutes ago. I will not be working nursery until all of this is clarified in the meeting with Pastor.

Even this decision would look poorly on my husband’s position as leader of our home, as confirmed by Tara Williams* later that evening. Having been a person that everyone went to for advice, she knew first-hand that the inner circle had specifically said that I was not submissive to my husband, and her gut-reaction was to encourage me to work nursery for the sake of my husband’s name and reputation. As we continued to discuss the situation, her stance changed about working nursery, but by this point, I understood why a majority of people left last fall, and I was almost ready to leave Antioch Baptist Church. My readiness quickly turned to resolve after the meeting with Pastor the following day (Sunday), and after Matt informed me of an additional calloused confrontation about my breastfeeding outside of the mother’s room.

In this series I share my thoughts and opinions concerning these ministers and the events which led to my departure. Click here to continue reading: “Blindsided: Our Own Pastor- Friend or Foe?” or click on the link below.

For a list of the complete series, click here.

********
Shop at our Amazon store! As an Amazon Influencer, this website earns from qualifying purchases.

“When a man asks a preacher to preach on a particularly controversial subject knowing that it will open that man to criticism from the fringe, the requester is an unscrupulous manipulator abusing friendships and position. #manipulator”– Douglas Stauffer, (June 5, 2018 at 8:25am)

Later in the week, we presume that Douglas Stauffer was feeling the heat for his statements because of the skeletons it brought into the light, and we feel that he turned around and blamed Pastor Andrew Ray for giving him the subject to preach on in the first place. How was Pastor Ray going to handle another man in the ministry, particularly his friend, practically attacking him online for all to see? Will Stauffer need to go around and apologize to everyone for his statement and will he be removed from all ministries?

According to Pastor Andrew Ray, Douglas Stauffer was referring to Steven Anderson, an outspoken Arizona pastor known for his highly controversial views and teachings on the end times. If that were the case, however, why did Pastor Andrew Ray request that Stauffer remove his post, and why did Douglas Stauffer offer to step down from being a Sunday school teacher because of the post?

Because Douglas Stauffer is staunchly and publicly against the teachings of Steven Anderson, I feel that if his post were truly about Anderson, Stauffer would have said it outright. Judge for yourselves, but in light of Stauffer and Ray’s previous actions, I feel this continues to support the ongoing hypocrisy between the leadership at Antioch Baptist Church and the ungodly influence of Douglas Stauffer.

In this series I share my thoughts and opinions concerning these ministers and the events which led to my departure. Click here to continue reading: “Blindsided: Still Expected to Cheer from the Nursery” or click on the link below.

For a list of the complete series, click here.

********
Shop at our Amazon store! As an Amazon Influencer, this website earns from qualifying purchases.

A little birdie once told me, “Actions speak louder than words.”

Less than twenty-four hours after Matthew Olds and I met with Douglas Stauffer at Antioch Baptist Church during the Bible Conference, Doug Stauffer shared the unedited YouTube video of his outrageous Sunday morning message on carnality. Though Stauffer’s sermon audio file for “The Hindrances to Building” was edited as we demanded in the meeting the night before, Stauffer “liked” and shared the unedited YouTube video long before proceeding with his agreement to remove his disgraceful comments. It was not until some time AFTER sharing the original unedited video, that he messaged Matt requesting a list of the specific times to edit from his sermon videos. Certainly, this revealed the heart of a man who was repentant of his “ill-advised” actions!

In this series I share my thoughts and opinions concerning these ministers and the events which led to my departure. Click here to continue reading: “Blindsided: Douglas Stauffer’s Twitter Tells All (Part Two)” or click on the link below.

For a list of the complete series, click here.

********
Shop at our Amazon store! As an Amazon Influencer, this website earns from qualifying purchases.

**Names marked with an asterisk (*) have been changed for the privacy of individuals and their families**

Our relief following the meeting with Douglas Stauffer was short-lived because Matthew Olds had previously planned on meeting with Pastor Andrew Ray to discuss the results of the meeting and because Matt further desired to make things right with our pastor. After breaking down in the meeting with Stauffer, I knew there was no way I would make it through a meeting with Pastor. Just in telling Matt that I never meant to hurt the pastor’s family, I would turn into a blubbering mess, hurting because of the pain I had caused them. Another layer of the tears stemmed from Pastor Ray’s stinging messages to my husband when he said that “the writing was on the wall” and that his daughter, Mary*, had lost a great deal of faith in me. I felt the weight of disappointing my pastor, letting him down and potentially damaging a precious teen girl in our youth group, and reviving depths of pain throughout our church. Even though Stauffer was the one who opened up the wounds, I felt that I was reason behind my pastor and his family hurting and there was no way I could get through a meeting with my pastor without getting choked up and crying uncontrollably.

When we went upstairs at the end of the Bible Conference meeting that Tuesday night, Matt met alone with Pastor Andrew Ray in one of the back sections of the church, while I paced in the lobby area awkwardly balancing carrying on small-talk and avoiding everyone’s gazes. Seated in the left section behind the folded wall, Pastor Ray inquired about the conversation with Doug Stauffer, and Matt responded that while it got heated at times, Stauffer and I (Crystal Olds) appeared to have reconciled things. Matt stated he could not conclude if Stauffer and I had actually forgiven each other because he could not get inside of our heads, but he reported that we both apologized and ended the meeting on a good note. To think that we were naïve enough to believe that everything could begin to calm down and that the worst may have been behind us.

Pastor Andrew Ray began, calmly, yet solemnly, to describe a time in his life when he was in a similar situation as Matt, back when he was the assistant pastor at Antioch Baptist Church under Pastor David Reagan. Pastor Ray continued about how he hurt some people and had to step down from all ministry activities for a time, but that he was eventually re-instated because of his faithfulness to church services. He proved himself to be faithful and Matt needed to do the same.

In my husband’s words, he was reduced to being the pastor’s cheerleader. He needed to be faithful to all services, continue to say “Amen,” and sing the hymns, and this would help regain “the confidence of the men of the church.” Matt was told that these were the only things he could do after we had already been pulled from serving in nursery and leading/organizing the greeter meeting. Because of my initial post about Doug Stauffer, Pastor Ray said that the men of the church had lost faith in my husband and that for now, just be faithful to the services, prove that we are not going to run off, and that eventually, he would come to Matt with something.

Pastor further informed Matt that a few men of the church- he later informed us of one, Nathaniel Morris- said they wanted to invest in him. When Matt inquired of Pastor as to where we go from here, Pastor suggested starting with Walter Gibson* considering that he had to go on one of my posts to provide context. Pastor then added that Walter might be able to direct Matt to the next person that he needed to apologize to, and then continue asking who to speak with next until he had made things right with everyone affected.

To say that my husband left that meeting entirely defeated would be an understatement, but he also left it fully believing that we had a loving and gracious pastor who had given out a merciful form of discipline in comparison to what it could have been. Matt swallowed his pride and choked it down, longing to serve the Lord and willing to do whatever was necessary to be able to do so. While Matt and I shared most of these same conclusions, I found pastor’s requirements for making things right- apologize to Walter, ask who he should apologize to next, apologize to that person, ask them who he should apologize to next- absolutely preposterous and unrealistic. It was more degrading and shaming than it was reconciling in any fashion. I further silently noted that encouraging Matt to say “Amen” was likely because the church services had been strangely quiet in that regard since the mass exodus of godly people the previous fall.

As was to be expected, however, Pastor’s requirements about service changed in what we feel was the face of not having enough people to do the work, a number that had already drastically declined with the mass exodus, and was then compounded by removing us from organizing and serving in the greeter ministry, and reducing one of the few available hands left in the nursery.

In this series I share my thoughts and opinions concerning these ministers and the events which led to my departure. Click here to continue reading: “Blindsided: Douglas Stauffer’s Twitter Tells All (Part One)” or click on the link below.

For a list of the complete series, click here.

********
Shop at our Amazon store! As an Amazon Influencer, this website earns from qualifying purchases.